A comparison essay 本文简介：
AComparisonofTwoVersionsofRomeoandJuliet?Shakespeare’sRomeoandJulietisoneofthemostadaptedtheatricalworksofall.Astimepasses,manydirectorshavemadefilmst
A comparison essay 本文内容：
A
Comparison
of
Two
Versions
of
Romeo
and
Juliet
?
Shakespeare’s
Romeo
and
Juliet
is
one
of
the
most
adapted
theatrical
works
of
all.
As
time
passes,
many
directors
have
made
films
that
change
the
origin
of
Romeo
and
Juliet.
Although
they
have
many
inherent
similarities,
they
are
still
very
different,
especially
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
and
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version.
This
essay
will
compare
and
contrast
these
two
critically
acclaimed
versions
of
the
play.
Overall,
there
are
three
main
differences
between
the
two
versions:
the
times
period,
the
characters’
personalities,
and
the
tableaus.
?
First,
one
main
difference
is
that
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
happened
in
ancient
times,
while
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
happened
in
current
times.
It
is
extremely
obviously
from
their
props,
buildings
and
costumes.
One
example
is
people
use
swords
to
fight,
and
use
horses
as
transportation
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version.
It
is
exceedingly
diverse
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
where
people
use
guns
to
attack,
cars
to
travel
and
electronic
invents
like
televisions
appear
in
the
movie.
Another
example
is
their
architecture
styles.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
the
styles
are
more
retro
as
they
are
made
of
stones.
In
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
the
buildings
are
more
modern
as
they
are
made
of
glass
and
cement
like
the
places
we
live
in
now.
At
the
same
time,
their
costumes
make
it
uncomplicated
to
see
the
differences.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
people
wear
the
customs
were
that
only
worn
by
the
ancient
people.
In
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
people
are
wearing
the
clothes
like
we
now
wearing.
The
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
happened
in
the
past
so
that
audiences
are
reminiscent
of
Shakespeare’s
time.
It
is
trying
to
make
the
play
more
convincing.
The
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
is
attempting
to
make
the
play
to
be
more
realistic
like
nowadays
so
that
it
can
be
easier
to
understand
by
modern
people.
Therefore,
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
took
place
in
ancient
times,
while
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
happened
in
current
times.?
The
second
main
difference
is
that
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
some
characters’
personalities
are
very
funny,
while
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
some
characters’
personalities
are
more
serious.
We
can
see
from
the
nurse,
Murcutio,
and
Romeo’s
friends.
When
Romeo’s
friends
are
playing
tricks
on
the
nurse,
the
nurse
is
annoyed
but
the
outcome
turns
out
to
be
an
amusing
scene
for
viewers.
Whereas
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
the
nurse
is
more
serious
and
does
not
like
the
puny
tricks
played
on
her.
The
whole
scene
is
not
like
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
to
amuse
audiences.
The
same
as
Mercutio
playing
fights
with
Tybolt.
Their
fighting
is
more
like
playing;
both
of
them
do
not
want
each
other
to
be
hurt
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version.
Indeed,
it
is
a
hilarious
scene.
On
the
other
hand,
it
is
opposite
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
that
both
of
them
want
to
kill
each
other
immediately.
The
atmosphere
is
tense
and
grave
in
this
scene
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version.
Furthermore,
Romeo’s
friends
give
different
reactions
in
both
versions
after
Mercutio
and
Tyboly’s
fighting.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
Romeo’s
friends
still
do
not
realize
Mercutio’s
crisis
and
all
of
them
are
in
a
cheerful
mood
until
they
find
Mercutio
is
dead.
But
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
Romeo’
friends
already
apprehend
the
seriousness
of
the
circumstances
of
Mercutio’s
life.
Above
all,
these
two
opposite
characterizations
in
the
two
versions
give
two
different
visions
of
Romeo
and
Juliet,
and
show
the
audience
one
more
sides
of
Romeo
and
Juliet.
Audiences
can
learn
more
about
Romeo
and
Juliet
by
comparing
the
opposite
characterizations
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
and
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version.
Therefore,
the
personalities
in
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
are
funnier,
while
the
personalities
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
are
more
serious.
?
The
third
difference
is
that
the
two
versions
give
the
audience
totally
different
tableaus.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
the
surroundings
are
a
slight
boring,
since
there
are
not
many
colors
in
the
play,
and
are
not
like
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
which
has
full
colorful
scenes.
The
scene
before
the
dancing
party
is
an
excellent
example.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
it
only
shows
two
colors,
black
and
red,
which
are
the
dark
night
and
the
glow
of
the
fire.
While
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
the
surroundings
are
much
better.
There
are
amount
of
colorful
fireworks
spread
out
of
the
sky.
Meanwhile,
Juliet’s
tomb
is
another
illustration
to
show
how
the
two
versions
give
two
different
tableaus.
In
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version,
it
is
not
enjoyable
to
see
that
scene
because
of
dire
backgrounds
of
Juliet’s
tomb.
It
is
incredibly
singular
to
see
Juliet’s
tomb
in
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version.
In
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version,
Juliet’s
tomb
is
full
of
candles
the
illumination
made
the
entire
room
affectionate
and
Juliet’s
body
looks
pure,
spiritual
and
peaceful
in
the
center
of
all
the
luminosity.
The
two
different
tableaus
give
people
quite
different
visual?feasts.
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
gives
a
feeling
of
romantic
and
imposingness.
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
is
less
imagination
and
not
vivid.
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
gives
a
more
comfortable
and
satisfied
feeling
like
a
fairy
tale
while
watching
the
play
than
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version.
Therefore,
the
tableau
of
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
is
less
lively,
and
the
tableau
of
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version
is
more
vibrant.
?
After
comparing
and
contrasting
the
versions
of
Romeo
and
Juliet.
It
is
not
difficult
to
find
the
differences
between
the
two
versions.
Both
of
them
are
wonderful
versions.
They
both
give
the
two
different
visions
of
Romeo
and
Juliet
as
well.
They
each
have
their
advantages
and
disadvantages.
The
differences
between
the
two
versions
are
the
times
periods,
characters’
personalities,
and
the
visual
feasts
of
two
different
tableaus.
It
is
a
pity
if
you
do
not
watch
the
two
versions
of
Romeo
and
Juliet,
which
are
Baz
Luhrmann’s
version
and
Franco
Zeffirelli’s
version.
What
are
you
waiting
for?
Take
a
rest
and
let
yourself
enjoy
the
two
different
versions
of
Shakespeare’s
Romeo
and
Juliet.
A comparison essay 本文关键词：comparison，essay
A comparison essay 来源：网络整理
免责声明：本文仅限学习分享，如产生版权问题，请联系我们及时删除。
《
A comparison essay》
由：
76范文网互联网用户整理提供,链接地址：
http://m.yuan0.cn/a/87055.html
免责声明：本文仅限学习分享，如产生版权问题，请联系我们及时删除。